Vấn đề tự đánh giá kết quả học tập thông qua ý kiến của giáo viên, học sinh và phụ huynh học sinh

VAN DE TU'DANH GIA KET QUA HOC TAP

O BUI THI HANH LAM*

Trong qud Irinh hinh thdnh vd phdt trien

nhdn edeh, sy hieu biet ve bdn thdn Id

mpl yeu td vd eung quon trpng. Khi ddnh

gid [DG] dung ve minh, ngudi to ed the xdc

dinh phuong hudng dung cho su ly gido dye

bdn thdn. Ndi khdc di, ly ddnh gid (TDG) Id

lien de dinh hudng euo ly gido dye.

Nhdm tim hieu so bd thye trqng kT ndng

lu TDG ke't qud hpe tdp (KQHT) cuo HS vd

viec ren luyen KN TDG KQHT cho HS trong

dqy hpe (DH) mdn Todn d trudng THPT, ehung

tdi dd lien hdnh dieu Ira, khdo sdt (11 /2008-

4/2009) d mdt sd trudng tren djo bdn linh

Thdi Nguyen (THPT Chu Vdn An - Gong

Thep), THPT Khdnh Hod - TP Thdi Nguyen),

THPT Nguyen Hue - Dpi Tu) vd mdt so GV

dqy lodn cdt edn eua ede trudng THPT d 4

linh Coo Bdng, Bde Kqn, Lqng San, Hd Giong

(11 /2008). Deed dupe thdng tin khdeh quan,

ehung tdi lien hdnh phdng vdn, dy gid, su

dyng phieu hdi... vdi ede ddi lugng Id edn

bd qudn li (CBQL), gido vien (GV), hpe sinh

(HS) vd phy huynh hpe sinh (PHHS) ve cdc

ndi dung, bien phdp: thue trong KN

TDGKQHT eua HS, ren luyen KN

TDGKQHTeho HS, nhi/ng gidi phdp md GV,

CBQL dd thuc hien de ren luyen KN

TDGKQHT eho HS...'

Quo dieu Iro, khdo sdt ehung tdi thu duoc

y kie'n eua 1 3 CBQL, 297 HS, 1 24 GV, 101

PHHS; dd phdng vdn 5 Idnh dpo cua ede

Irudng, cdn bd ehuyen mdn cua sd; 10 GV

lodn; 1 5 HS vd d PHHS. Kel qud:

1. Phdn hdi dd'i vdi GV vd CBQL

1) Ve quan niem TDG KQHT cua HS.

Ddy Id vdn de mdi, do dd ehung tdi cung

mudn hdi y kien cuo GV, CBQLve quan niem

ehung tdi duo ra. 89% GV duge hdi deu

nhdt Iri vdi quon niem ndy; 0, 4% GV khdng

nhd't tri; 0,7% chua rd, khdng oi dua ro quan

niem khde.

2) Ve vai trd cua KN T€>C KQHT vd su can thiet

ren luyen KN TDG KQHT cua HS (xem bdng 1,

bdng 2).

Bdng I. So lugng doi tugng dong -y vdi cdc y hoi

ve vai fro cua KN TDG KQHT

___B6i tuong duoc hoi

Noi dung hoi ~—-—___

Giup HS tang them hting thtJ hpc tap,

phat huy tinh doc lap

Giiip muc tieu hpc tap trd nen ro rang,

day manh tinh huong dich, tao dieu kien

de nguoi hoc dat duoc muc tieu hoc tap

Chia se trach nhiem danh gia ciing vdi GV

Hoc tap tich cLTc, tu giac, chij dong

Y kien khac

CBQL

(13)

12

13

13

13

0

GV

(124)

109

113

90

107

0

Bdng 2. Y kien dong y ve su cdn thief ren luyen

KN TDG KQHT cho HS

—_____D6i tL/png difOc hoi

Cac mirc dp _

Rat can thiet

Can thiet

Chua c§n thiet

Khong can thiet

CBQL

62%

30%

8%

GV

(124)

49%

50%

1%

Khi phdng vdn trye tie'p do sd GV, CBQL deu eho

rdng, KN TDG KQHT eua HS Id rdt edn thie'l vi nd

giup eho HS hpc tap ehu ddng hem vd cd trdch nhiem

han vai viec hpe tap eua bdn thdn, mpl so rdt il eho

rdng chuo edn Idm vi viec DG hpe tap eua HS Idu nay

vdn ehi do GV nen HS se khdng ly gide, lich eye khi

TDG KQHT euo bdn thdn minh,

3) Ve thuc trgng KN TDG KQHT cua HS. Khi hdi

GV vd CBQL ve KN TDG KQHT cuo HS, 53% cho rang

HS ed KN TDG, 47% eho Id HS chuo ed KN ndy, Hdi

ve mue dp KN TDG KQHT hien ed cuo HS, 74% cho Id

KN TDG KQHT cuo HS d mue do thdp, 25% eho Id d

mue dp trung binh vd 1 % eho Id tdt,

De hieu rd hem thye trpng ndy, chung tdi dd phdng

vdn mdl sd GV vd CBQL, do sd ddi lugng dugc phdng

* Tnrong Dai hpc sir pham - DH Thai Nguyen

Tap ciii Giao due so 23 0 (ki 2 -1/2010)