Thư viện tri thức trực tuyến
Kho tài liệu với 50,000+ tài liệu học thuật
© 2023 Siêu thị PDF - Kho tài liệu học thuật hàng đầu Việt Nam

The broadcast journalism handbook
Nội dung xem thử
Mô tả chi tiết
THE BROADCAST JOURNALISM
HANDBOOK
GARY HUDSON & SARAH ROWLANDS
THE BROADCAST JOURNALISM HANDBOOK
THE BROADCAST JOURNALISM HANDBOOK HUDSON & ROWLANDS
Gary Hudson
is Head of Broadcast
Journalism at Staffordshire
University. He is a former
BBC TV reporter and has
worked in independent
television and radio.
Sarah Rowlands
is Head of Journalism at
Staffordshire University. She
is a radio and TV producer,
and has won 14 national
awards for her work with
the BBC and independent
television.
Between them the authors
have more than sixty years’
experience in radio and
television.
‘There is, more than ever, a need for a book … that takes us deep into the
jungle of politics, ethics and the law. Well, here it is.’ Jeremy Vine
www.pearson-books.com
This exciting, comprehensive and bang up-to-date text presents all the key practical skills
required by today’s broadcast journalist. Highly illustrated with examples from modern-day
newsrooms, the authors explain in detail the key techniques and theoretical context the
broadcast journalist will need to know to succeed.
Main features
Comprehensive coverage of all the key skills, such as news gathering, interviewing, writing
and story-telling, live/location-reporting, online, editing, graphics and presentation – each
explained with examples from the best-known names in British broadcasting
Newsdays section, covering both radio and TV, shows the excitement, pressure and key
events of days in real-life newsrooms
Essential Guide section provides the tools – how to get a job, an easy guide to the law,
and an up-to-date glossary of broadcasting terms
Workshops section gives opportunities to practise key skills
Accommodates all the technical, regulatory and theoretical advances in recent broadcast
custom and practice, including online news, and digital interactive services
Covers cutting-edge technology the broadcast journalist must know – mobile video
production, graphics and digital journalism for any broadcast platform
Case studies, ‘Thinkpieces’ and key summary boxes provide context, extension and
assistance
Companion website (www.pearsoned.co.uk/practicaljournalism) includes updates on new
developments, podcasts and further support materials
DVD demonstrates fi lming techniques and editing ideas
This is a core text for college, university and independent training courses in broadcast
journalism at all levels, and for professionals and trainees in broadcast, print and other media
looking to develop their skills. It is also for those viewing broadcast journalism in the wider context
of media studies or perhaps considering a career, or those just fascinated by the profession.
‘It will be invaluable in university journalism departments, on professional
training courses, and in the broadcast newsroom itself. I would certainly adopt
this for my students.’ Mike Henfi eld, University of Salford
‘I think this book is new, up-to-date and of the moment and I would
recommend it to our students.’ Jennifer Brown, University of Leeds
‘It is very well written and comprehensive too. I especially like the examples,
which are recent and all highly relevant.’ Roy Saatchi of Roy Saatchi Associates
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
P
L
J Longman Practical Journalism
with a foreword by
Jeremy Vine
Cover photographs:
Gary Hudson & Sarah Rowlands DVD included
9781405824347_COVER.indd 1 10/4/07 13:40:52
THE BROADCAST JOURNALISM
HANDBOOK
Visit The Broadcast Journalism Handbook Companion Website at
www.pearsoned.co.uk/practicaljournalism to find valuable
learning material including:
• Updates on the latest developments in news
broadcasting
• Audio interviews
• Links to relevant online resources
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page i
We work with leading authors to develop the
strongest educational materials in journalism
and media studies, bringing cutting-edge
thinking and best learning practice to
a global market.
Under a range of well-known imprints, including
Longman, we craft high quality print and electronic
publications which help readers to understand
and apply their content, whether studying or at work.
To find out more about the complete range of our
publishing, please visit us on the World Wide Web at:
www.pearsoned.co.uk
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page ii
THE BROADCAST JOURNALISM
HANDBOOK
GARY HUDSON & SARAH ROWLANDS
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page iii
Pearson Education Limited
Edinburgh Gate
Harlow
Essex CM20 2JE
England
and Associated Companies throughout the world
Visit us on the World Wide Web at:
www.pearsoned.co.uk
First published 2007
© Pearson Education Limited 2007
The rights of Gary Hudson and Sarah Rowlands to be identified as authors of this work have
been asserted by them in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval
system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying,
recording or otherwise, without either the prior written permission of the publisher or
a licence permitting restricted copying in the United Kingdom issued by the Copyright
Licensing Agency Ltd, Saffron House, 6–10 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TS.
All trademarks used herein are the property of their respective owners. The use of any
trademark in this text does not vest in the author or publisher any trademark ownership
rights in such trademarks, nor does the use of such trademarks imply any affiliation with
or endorsement of this book by such owners.
ISBN: 978-1-4058-2434-7
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
11 10 09 08 07
Typeset in 9.5/12.5pt Din Regular by 35
Printed and bound by Graficus Estella, Bilbao, Spain
The publisher’s policy is to use paper manufactured from sustainable forests.
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page iv
Foreword vii
Preface viii
Author acknowledgements x
Publisher acknowledgements xi
Guided tour xii
Part One: The Job 1
Chapter One Introduction 3
Chapter Two What’s the story? 19
Chapter Three Finding the news 50
Chapter Four The interview 87
Chapter Five News writing 128
Chapter Six Location reporting and production 164
Chapter Seven Location video and sound 188
Chapter Eight Sports reporting and commentary 220
Chapter Nine Foreign reporting 237
Chapter Ten Going live 261
Chapter Eleven The package 278
Chapter Twelve Editing 303
Chapter Thirteen Graphics 319
Chapter Fourteen Presentation 332
Chapter Fifteen The programme 357
Part Two: Newsdays 393
Sky News 396
BBC Radio Five Live 404
ITN 422
BBC Ten O’Clock News 440
101–102 Century FM 454
BBC News 24 473
Staffordshire News 488
Radio 1 Newsbeat 510
CONTENTS
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page v
CONTENTS
vi
Part Three: The Essential Guide 527
Getting a job 529
The law and broadcast journalists 535
Glossary 544
Part Four: Workshops and Exercises 557
Workshops and Exercises 559
Index 565
Supporting resources
Visit www.pearsoned.co.uk/practicaljournalism to find valuable online
resources
Companion Website
• Updates on the latest developments in news broadcasting
• Audio interviews
• Links to relevant online resources
For more information please contact your local Pearson Education sales
representative or visit www.pearsoned.co.uk/practicaljournalism
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page vi
FOREWORD
How do you learn to broadcast? I've never worked out the answer to that
question. When I was a teenager, engrossed in the idea of being on the radio
because of a fleeting visit I'd paid to Capital at the age of 12, I thought you needed
a Physics O Level. That would give me an understanding of the way a transmitter
worked, I reckoned; what caused feedback; why speakers have magnets.
'Nonsense,' said a friend. 'You don't need to know any of that.'
So I bought a book instead. In those days, there was only one book. I remember
the title as Being a DJ by Emperor Roscoe. A great read it was too – all about how
to avoid losing records on your way to a gig. Presenters were gods when I was
young. They did not write books. DJs did not talk about how to broadcast. Maybe
nobody did.
Spool on a few decades. London is making a claim to be the media capital of
the world, and now your digital dial shows up, not only Capital, but a score
of other stations. The TV has 250 channels! The media hoover up thousands
and thousands of young and aspiring journalists, presenters, producers and
technicians (now with Physics GCSEs). There is, more than ever, a need for a
book that does quite a bit more than Roscoe could, that takes us deep into the
jungle of politics, ethics and the law. Well, here it is.
Good luck.
Jeremy Vine
March 2007
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page vii
PREFACE
A few weeks back I had lunch in Dublin with one of my former students, Richard
Hannaford. We had last met over 20 years ago. Since then he had risen to be BBC
Health Correspondent, but left the Corporation some years ago and is now one
of Ireland’s most successful periodical publishers, with a stable of magazines
which includes the country’s highest selling women’s magazine. We took the
opportunity to reminisce about his fellow alumni, and it was impressive to realise
how well they had done. I even managed to retrieve my 1984 assessment notes
from a dark corner of our loft and was impressed to find that some of those who
had been quite moderate performers as student broadcasters had nonetheless
enjoyed major success on the business side of the media. Like Richard and me,
few were still active frontline broadcast journalists, yet many are still using the
core journalism skills they have learnt and developed over the years. And I guess
that, in the finest tradition of the Blairite nanny state, is the point at which we
ought to state the almost mandatory caveat.
The clear factual evidence provided by the regular Skillset media industry surveys
shows that there are relatively fewer active broadcast journalists over 40 and
even fewer who make it through the fifties to a comfortable retirement living off
anecdotes of derring-do with nothing but a microphone to protect them from the
wild elements or an even wilder mob.
Yet the growth in demand for professional, accredited training as a broadcast
journalist is starting to outstrip more traditional disciplines.
At the time of writing the Broadcast Journalism Training Council already
accredits 32 courses, and that number will rise steeply over the next two or
three years, with yet more degree and other courses set to launch after that. We
are repeatedly asked where are all the graduates of these courses going to find
jobs – yet no one ever asked in the past where the graduates from the various
traditional academic courses like history, politics and philosophy were going
to find work – after all there’s hardly ever been a point in history when there’s
been a burgeoning bull market in philosophers.
For a start, the best graduates will enter the industry, fully and far better
equipped to take rapid advantage of the many emerging career opportunities
than journalists of my generation could ever have imagined. We learnt ‘on
the job’ and believe me, it’s an often painful and embarrassing process.
As this book so powerfully and entertainingly demonstrates, with so many
enlightening real-life examples and anecdotes, you will learn how to go straight
to the heart of a story, of an idea or a concept; you will learn how to write clearly,
succinctly and, hopefully, all in good, properly spelt and grammatical English.
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page viii
PREFACE
ix
You will learn about presenting what you have written in print, sound and vision
across an ever widening range of platforms; about interviewing people and
allowing them to present themselves and their views persuasively. Not only that,
you will also learn to speak to a microphone, to a camera and even to a live
audience in a clear and confident manner. You will learn technical skills and
how to use a range of computer software and, on a personal level, you will learn
how to organise yourself and your time and to work as part of a team and, in time,
to lead those teams. You might even learn shorthand, the most traditional of
journalism skills, but evermore relevant even in this hi-tech post-Hutton world,
though Hutton should be the least of your reasons for so doing.
I believe there can be few people who could argue that these are not highly
valuable and highly transferable skills, with a far wider and longer-term
application than many other traditional academic degrees – and there is little
danger that journalism and communications skills will ever become obsolete,
because they are at the core of the burgeoning information society. But this
book is just a beginning. You will need to ensure that you continue to refresh,
upgrade and broaden those skills through a continuing programme of personal
and professional development. Again, this is a concept largely alien to previous
generations of journalists – after all, in nearly 25 years as a print, radio and
finally a television journalist, I refreshed my skills in a properly structured way
only twice, which is why I have become so committed to high quality, fully
accredited training and continuing personal and professional development.
The broadcast and media environment is changing at a faster pace than I can
ever recall. We are entering a third age of broadcasting, where traditional linear
models, both print and electronic, are starting to look creakingly obsolete. There
are newer, smarter technologies and software – digital TV, Wi-Fi, broadband,
iPods, DAB, DRM – simply too many to remember, let alone name.
Such is the pace of change that even as I write I feel a second edition of this book
coming on, but however good this book is, it ultimately rests with you to make the
best of your skills, your abilities and your opportunities. Best of luck.
Steve Harris
Accreditations Secretary
Broadcast Journalism Training Council
November 2006
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page ix
AUTHOR ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This book is the product of a year and a half’s research and two lifetimes in
broadcasting. It would not have been possible without the enthusiasm and
support of all the professionals who welcomed us into their workplaces and
homes, and generously shared their ideas, experiences and working practices.
We have tried to distil as much as possible of their expertise into its pages.
Any mistakes are entirely the authors’.
We particularly thank Vin Ray and Helen Boaden at the BBC, Rob Kirk and Pete
Lowe at Sky News and Deborah Turness at ITN for facilitating our visits to their
organisations. Except where otherwise stated, quotes come from interviews
conducted by the authors. We are grateful to all who gave permissions to
reproduce copyright material.
The panel of referees, assembled by Pearson Education from the broadcast
industries, educational institutions (Jan Whyatt at City University, Jennifer
Brown at Leeds, Carole Fleming at Nottingham Trent and others who wished to
remain anonymous) and the BJTC (especially Steve Harris), improved our work
immeasurably. Particular gratitude must go to Roy Saatchi and Mike Henfield,
whom we knew to be great news editors from the time we worked with them, and
who have brought the same sharp insight and good humour to their suggestions
for the text.
We could not have completed this project without the support of colleagues at
Staffordshire University, who covered for us whenever we were away from the
day job, and shared our excitement as the book came together.
Andrew Taylor and the team at Pearson, and Lissy Kowalski, who made sense of
more than a thousand photographs and helped edit them down to what you see
in the book, shaped the finished product.
Final thanks to our families, who tolerated the late nights in the office and the
days away from home.
Gary Hudson
Sarah Rowlands
November 2006
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page x
We are grateful to the following for permission to reproduce copyright material:
P8 (main), p160, p174 (2nd main) p323, p324 (2nd) and p324 (3rd) photos and
graphics reprinted by permission of BBC Worldwide; p8 (t) & 252, p300, p324
(2nd from top) & p324 (b) and p327 photos reprinted by permission of BSkyB Ltd.;
screenshots on p305(b), p308 and p352 (b) screen shot frames reprinted with
permission from Microsoft Corporation; p122 © Horace Whetton (Staffordshire
University); p305 (b) screenshot from RadioMan® Quick Edit Pro reprinted by
permission of Jutel Oy; p308 screenshot from Avid Xpress DV reprinted courtesy
of Avid Technology, Inc.; graphics on p326 (top 5) Curious World Map images
from www.curious-software.com reprinted by permission of Vizrt Ltd.; p385
screenshot from BBC News at bbc.co.uk/news reprinted by permission of
BBC News Interactive.
We are grateful to the following for permission to reproduce text material:
Chapter 2, Theories of news production, adapted extract from Investigating
the Media, reprinted by permission of HarperCollins Publishers Ltd. © Paul
Trowler 1988 (Trowler, P. 1988); Chapter 3, Chapter 4, Chapter 6 and Chapter 15
extracts from BBC Editorial Guidelines, reproduced by kind permission of the
BBC; Chapter 6 abridged extract from Guidelines for MPS staff on dealing with
media reporters, press photographers and television crews, produced by the
Directorate of Public Affairs, © 2006 Metropolitan Police Authority, reprinted by
permission of Metropolitan Police Service; Chapter 9 The INSI Safety Code from
www.newssafety.com/safety/index.htm, © International News Safety Institute,
reprinted by permission of International News Safety Institute; Chapter 9, Case
Study: Explaining the world – a foreign reporter at work, Laurence Lee’s report
from Russia prior to the presidential elections of 2004, broadcast on Sky News,
reprinted by permission of BSkyB Ltd.; Chapter 11, Case Study: Pulling it together
– using actuality, Rachel Harvey’s report on the Indonesian earthquake, broadcast
on BBC Radio 4 18:00 bulletin, 31 May 2006, reproduced by kind permission of
the BBC and Rachel Harvey; Chapter 11 Robin Punt’s interview with Noel Martin,
broadcast on BBC Midlands, June 2006, reproduced by kind permission of the
BBC, Robin Punt and Noel Martin; Chapter 11 Case Study: War Artist, Rob Perry’s
story broadcast on BBC local TV West Midlands, reproduced by kind permission of
the BBC and Rob Perry; Chapter 13 Case Study: Working with blue screen – the
virtual reality graphic, Chris Evans interview with Jeremy Vine and Peter Snow,
broadcast on BBC Radio 2, Chris Evans Show, 4 May 2006, reproduced by kind
permission of the BBC, Chris Evans, Jeremy Vine and Peter Snow.
In some instances we have been unable to trace the owners of copyright material,
and we would appreciate any information that would enable us to do so.
PUBLISHER
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page xi
PART ONE THE JOB
74
Sky News has a reputation for being first with breaking news, but the man who
presided over the growth of that reputation, Nick Pollard, has another passion:
‘Accuracy, accuracy, accuracy. It certainly drives me mad and I hope that it drives
younger people mad to see anything wrong.’
GETTING IT WRONG
The tragic consequences of getting it wrong were illustrated in January 2006
when the world’s media reported that 12 miners had survived underground
after a pit explosion in West Virginia. For nearly three hours waiting families
celebrated before they were told that all but one of the men had, in fact, died.
The mistake was apparently due to a misheard radio message from rescuers
to their command centre. As the euphoria at a ‘miracle escape’ spread, no
journalist appears to have checked with authoritative sources, because there
were no authoritative sources. The command centre had issued no official
statement. Church bells pealed in celebration and the rolling news channels
duly broadcast those celebrations. The reporters possibly got too close to the
story and were caught up in the excitement of the miners’ families. The result:
misinformation was reported as fact.
Writing in the Guardian soon afterwards, media consultant and Internet blogger
Jeff Jarvis wrote: ‘Hours after the terrible truth emerged, network executives
and newspaper editors fell over themselves issuing justifications and excuses:
they listed their sources and said they did the best they could with what they
were given.’
Jarvis said the lesson of this was: ‘You can’t trust the news.’ He argued that,
in an age of instant communication and constant coverage, the public was left
to judge the reliability of the news for themselves. ‘The public is the editor.’
News, Jarvis said, is not a product, it’s a process. ‘It is time for journalists to
tell the audience not just what they know, but also what they do not know. And
it is time for journalists to admit that, in the end, they don’t decide what is true.
The public makes that judgement. So journalists must arm the public to do
that job. We get to the truth together.’
CASE STUDY 3.1
The Internet as a research tool
The importance of checking sources is never more critical than when taking
information from the Internet. The World Wide Web is a fabulous resource for
journalists. Search engines offer immediate information at our fingertips. But
there is no guarantee that any of the information is reliable.
Learn to focus your searches, and identify which sites can be trusted. If you
are searching for an old news story about a topic, on Google for example, refine
your search to ‘news’. If you are looking for the website of a British organisation,
select ‘pages from the UK’. If you are looking for pictures, select ‘images’.
Use quotation marks to refine your search. If you are looking for information
about Roy Saatchi (a former BBC editor), you won’t want information about
PART ONE THE JOB
90
PREPARING FOR AN INTERVIEW
KNOWING WHAT YOU WANT FROM AN INTERVIEW
Remember the five ‘W’s? As we explain in Chapter 2: What’s the story? and
Chapter 5: News writing the information presented in a news story can be
summed up by answering the questions ‘who, what, where, when, why (and how)’.
It follows that your questions in any interview will almost certainly start with
those words. But before you start asking questions there is only one of those
words that matters. That word is ‘why’. Why are you conducting the interview?
Why do you want to talk to this person? Why will this interview help tell the story?
Often the answer is to find a soundbite – a short clip that sums up somebody’s
opinion or reaction. You need to focus on the key question that will elicit that
response. There’s no point recording a five-minute interview when you only want
a 20-second answer. Equally there’s no point running through the five ‘W’s. Those
will have been answered earlier in the piece. Colour and drama will result from a
more relaxed approach: ‘Hey, did it hurt?’
When you know why you are conducting the interview you can decide what questions
to ask. Ask yourself: ‘What do I want to know?’ and structure the interview
accordingly. If it is to learn the facts about a news event, then it is an interview to
gain information. If it is to challenge an authority figure, then it is investigative or
adversarial. If it is to elicit a personal response to events, it will be an emotional
interview. Sometimes you will be talking to someone simply because of who they
are – the celebrity interview. But you still need to be clear why.
In any interview, be bold. And don’t be afraid to be nosey. As long as you are polite,
you should dare to ask the questions to which everybody wants the answers.
CHECK LIST
REMEMBER
➤ What is the point of the story?
➤ Why am I asking these questions?
➤ What do I need to know?
➤ What can this person tell me that others cannot?
➤ How can I get the best from this interviewee?
➤ How can I make them trust me?
➤ Which part of their story needs challenging?
➤ What conclusions will the audience draw from this interview, or from the
clip I choose?
TIP BOX
RESEARCH AND PREPARATION FOR INTERVIEWS
Research and preparation are central to all successful broadcasting. But never
more so than when preparing to interview somebody. This is usually the first
THERE’S NO POINT
RECORDING A FIVEMINUTE INTERVIEW
WHEN YOU ONLY
WANT A 20-SECOND
ANSWER.
CHAPTER TWO WHAT’S THE STORY?
47
The significance of sport to the community was one of the factors stressed by the
London bid team which successfully won the 2012 Olympic Games for Britain.
The TUC and the CBI (the ‘voices’ of trades unions and employers respectively)
issued pleas to British companies to allow workers to keep in touch with the test
match score during the crucial climax to cricket’s 2005 Ashes series.
The veteran broadcaster, legendary interviewer and sometime sportswriter
Michael Parkinson summed up the appeal of sport in his Daily Telegraph column
shortly after that England Ashes victory: ‘The importance of sport is that it doesn’t
matter, except as an antidote to things that do.’
BRITAIN’S FIRST SPORTS NEWS CHANNEL
Sport’s appeal is reflected in the success of Sky Sports News. The channel
was set up after Rupert Murdoch’s Sky Television bought up a huge swathe of
sports rights, revolutionising the way sport was viewed on UK television. The
range of live sport available to viewers increased exponentially – as did the
cost of watching it. Sky’s impressive roster of live sport meant there was also
a growing library of highlights to exploit. Those highlights could be shown
on the Sky News channel, and there was also enough to provide raw material
for a stand-alone sports news channel. Sky Sports News would serve as a
promotional tool for the premium-cost sports channels and for pay-per-view
events. Even with the cost of employing presenters and reporters, it virtually
paid for itself.
As a business model it was inspired. As a response to audience demand, it has
more than justified itself, regularly attracting more viewers than the ‘senior’
service Sky News.
A CLOSER LOOK
REMEMBER
➤ Sports news matters to a large proportion of the audience
➤ Ignorance of sport will find you out.
. . . and finally
The phrase ‘and finally’ has become such a cliché of broadcasting that it is rarely
used other than ironically. But a well-rounded bulletin on all but the hardest
news day will almost always end on a lighter note. The ‘and finally’ will usually
be a human interest story, treated with humour. Greg Dyke, when he was
Director General of the BBC, warned journalists to leave comedy to comedians.
Nonetheless, a strong tradition has developed, particularly in regional TV news,
of reporters offering a wry and affectionate look at life’s eccentricities. The style
was set by great names in broadcasting like Fyfe Robertson and Alan Whicker on
the BBC’s Tonight in the early days of TV magazine programmes half a century
ago, and was continued by regional reporters on news magazines. John Swallow
on Central News and John Yates on BBC Midlands Today earned the affection of
Midlands viewers across three decades. Chas Watkin, now a senior BBC regional
news editor, says: ‘When I was growing up, my sister and I used to watch the ITV
programme just waiting for John Swallow’s piece to come on.’
PART ONE THE JOB
60
AN ETHICAL DILEMMA
Protests are good copy. They can turn ugly, leading to clashes with opponents
or the police. The Poll Tax demonstrations in Margaret Thatcher’s era turned
into riots. The Countryside Alliance’s demonstration against the Fox Hunting
Ban under Tony Blair’s premiership led to confrontation with police in riot
gear.
Often broadcasters will be told about a demo in advance – even before the
police or other authorities know about it. That is because the protestors want
publicity for their actions. Public opinion is their principal weapon. It helps
their case if they get coverage even before the police arrive. To what extent
is it acceptable for broadcasters to collude in what might turn into criminal
activity?
The Ofcom code says material likely to encourage or incite the commission
of crime or to lead to disorder must not be included in television or radio
services. But that does not prevent journalists attending illegal
demonstrations.
The BBC Editorial Guidelines say ‘comprehensive coverage of demonstrations,
disturbances and riots is an important part of our news reporting,’ but:
• ‘We assess the risk that by previewing likely prospects of disturbances we
might encourage them.
• We withdraw immediately if we suspect we are inflaming the situation.
• We treat estimates of involvement with due scepticism and report wide
disparities and name the sources of the figures.’
There are also special rules for live reporting. There must be a delay in
transmission, or the chance to cut away and record material for use in
an edited report, if the level of violence or disorder becomes too graphic.
THINKPIECE
right. The decision in the BBC not to rely on unchecked local radio copy was
controversial within the organisation at the time, but it vastly reduced the
number of basic journalistic mistakes, like names, places and facts that
were wrong. Mostly mistakes happened because accurate spelling was
not essential in radio and it is online. Other errors were easier for the
audience to spot because web pages are permanent while the spoken
word is transient.
Hugh Berlyn, Editor of BBC News Interactive, English Regions, sums up the
change in approach:
It used to be the case that online journalists in the BBC were just processing
other people’s stories. The attitude was, ‘We don’t need more journalists,
we’ve got plenty in television and radio.’ But since we decided not to rely on
local radio copy, that has changed. Our people have to be content providers.
They know how to source a story and they know right from wrong. True,
they don’t get out of the office much, but that’s true of regional newspapers
these days.
Hugh Berlin, Editor of
BBC News Interactive,
English Regions
MATERIAL LIKELY
TO ENCOURAGE
OR INCITE THE
COMMISSION
OF CRIME OR TO
LEAD TO DISORDER
MUST NOT BE
INCLUDED IN
TELEVISION OR
RADIO SERVICES.
PART ONE THE JOB
GUIDED TOUR
Remember – a quick
summary/revision aid
of the key points at the
end of each section
A closer look box –
focuses on a key topic
or issue from the main
text in more detail
Thinkpiece box – encourages the reader to
consider some of the issues – perhaps
ethical, practical or legal - central to
working as an informed broadcast
journalist
Case study box – looks
in more detail at a
particular (often real)
case or scenario in
broadcast journalism
Tip box – pithy advice
showing key techniques
and practices in
broadcast journalism
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page xii
PART ONE THE JOB
302
REMEMBER
➤ Online story-telling can be non-linear – the user chooses a way through
the content
➤ Combine text, stills, graphics, video, audio and user content
➤ Online packages can appeal to different target audiences at the same time
➤ Use graphics programmes like Flash
➤ Make your package interactive for users.
CONCLUSIONS
The traditional TV or radio package is probably as good a way of telling a linear
story as has ever been devised. All the elements can be edited and crafted into
an easily digested form that’s convenient for viewers and listeners to understand.
But there are new horizons and new challenges. The limits of non-linear storytelling have yet to be explored. There is clearly an appetite for the new form.
Many young people prefer playing video games to watching TV. They still use TV,
but fewer are engaged by scheduled news programmes. Interactive journalism
offers a way to attract that audience, and the opportunity to expand the limitations
of traditional broadcast journalism.
FURTHER READING
Chantler, Paul and Stewart, Peter (2003) Basic Radio Journalism, Oxford:
Focal Press. Expertise on producing wraps and features for radio.
McAdams, Mindy (2005) Flash Journalism: How to create mulitmedia news
packages, Oxford: Focal Press. The definitive guide to using Macromedia’s Flash
in web journalism.
Ray, Vin (2003) The Television News Handbook, London: Macmillan. TV reporting
explained with many examples from senior practioners.
WEB LINKS
www.flashjournalism.com. Mindy McAdams’ site.
www.newsday.com. A first-class example of Flash Journalism.
www.viewmagazine.tv. David Dunkley Gyimah’s web-based magazine The View
with examples of packaged TV reports.
0600
Sky News
Sky News was the UK’s first rolling 24-hour news channel. Part of Rupert
Murdoch’s News Corporation, it has regularly won awards as Britain’s top
rolling news channel. It is on satellite, cable and digital terrestrial TV. It has
interactive and mobile phone services too.
In late 2005, Sky News moved to a purpose-built studio complex across the road
from its original base on a trading estate in Osterley, West London. The move
coincided with a redesign of the channel, and a switch to widescreen broadcasting.
The programme schedule was refreshed, with dedicated shows aimed at different
audience demands throughout the day.
The channel’s unique selling point (USP) is that it is first for breaking news.
Channel head Nick Pollard, who ran the operation for ten years, asserted: ‘We
can’t afford to be on background or analysis when there’s a breaking story.’ So,
each programme was constructed so it could be broken into at any time to deliver
major news.
The programmes changed when John Ryley took over from Pollard in summer
2006, but the commitment remained to build on the reputation for breaking
news with specialist correspondents delivering more original journalism.
When we visited Sky, ITV had announced the closure of its rolling news channel,
leaving Sky News and BBC News 24 competing head-to-head. According to a
senior Sky News manager, the two big players had their tanks parked on each
other’s lawns.
Sunrise, Sky’s breakfast programme, goes on air. It is co-presented by Eamonn Holmes,
one of the UK’s most popular broadcasters, famous as the host of GMTV’s breakfast
show and of the lottery, quizzes and factual light entertainment on the BBC. Lorna
Dunkley co-hosts, with Jacquie Beltrao on sport.
The opening story is a Sky exclusive about the rescue of a Midlands woman from a
forced marriage in Pakistan. The film, following a foreign office rescue team backed up
by armed police, is the result of nine months’ investigation, research and persuasion by
reporter Eve Richings.
At the home news desk next to the studio, Senior Home News Editor Kirsty Thomsonhas
just come on shift. She’s been briefed about overnight developments on stories the
channel is covering. She’ll keep track of crews and reporters across the UK, and keep
an eye on what the opposition is doing on a multi-screen display on her desktop. Nick
Toksvig is on the foreign desk, co-ordinating input from correspondents around the world.
Broadcast journalists operate within a legal framework, regulated by the
statutory bodies which govern broadcasting (in the UK, Ofcom) and the laws
of the land (which differ in Scotland from the rest of the UK).
This is a guide to the areas of law and court practice of which journalists have
to be aware. It is not a substitute for the law modules run within accredited
broadcast journalism courses, or the information found in specialist books
(McNae’s Essential Law for Journalists, the core text, runs to over 500 pages).
Law comes from a variety of sources:
• Custom – established practice (known as common law)
• Precedent – the application of earlier decisions to a current case (case law)
• Statute – Acts of Parliament (statutory instruments)
• European Union regulations
• The European Convention on Human Rights.
In Scotland, there are also ‘writers’, institutional texts from respected writers
on Scots law, mostly from the seventeenth, eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.
Equity, the concept of natural justice and fairness, informs all the UK’s legal
systems.
DEFAMATION
Defamation is probably the biggest risk faced by working journalists. Whenever
you write about someone, there is a danger you will damage their reputation,
sometimes unwittingly. A spoken defamatory statement is slander, except
where it is spoken in a broadcast (or in a public performance of a play). Then
it has the same status as a statement in print and is defined as libel.
Civil actions for libel in pursuit of damages may be taken out against a
broadcaster by anyone who considers they have been defamed. There is also,
much more rarely, a risk of criminal libel, where the publication might lead to
a breach of the peace.
Juries have to decide if reasonable men and women would consider a statement
defamatory. Does it:
1 expose the person to hatred, ridicule or contempt?
2 cause him (or her) to be shunned or avoided?
3 lower him in the estimation of right-thinking members of society generally? or
4 disparage him in his business, trade or profession?
THE LAW AND BROADCAST
JOURNALISTS
GUIDED TOUR
xiii
End of chapter –
weblinks and further
reading encourage
you to look further
Essential Guide section –
provides the tools the
broadcast journalist needs
Workshops section – gives
opportunities to practice
key skills
Website – keeps you up to date
with the latest developments
in news broadcasting and
provides interviews with experts
DVD – explains and
demonstrates radio and
television recording
techniques
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION
• Track the progress of a news story on different
platforms from the same news organisation (the BBC
and Sky News offer TV, radio, online and mobile phone
services). How do the length and treatment of the story
differ on:
1 Terrestrial television news
2 Rolling news
3 Radio bulletins
4 The website
5 Broadband services
6 Mobile phones.
• Visit the website of a major news provider. How many
different types of job do they offer in broadcast
journalism? Find out the roles of:
1 A field producer in TV
2 A foreign news editor
3 A TV researcher
4 A regional TV programme producer
5 A radio reporter in commercial radio.
• Prepare a background file on a running story – e.g.
conflict in the Middle East, the next US presidential
election, the London Olympics. Select stories that are
new developments or related to the same issue. Order
them in a folder (preferably electronically as downloads
or weblinks, or, if not, in the form of newspaper
cuttings). Whenever there is a new angle on the story,
consult your files and see how that helps your
understanding of the story.
CHAPTER TWO: WHAT’S THE STORY?
• Who do you think is the typical listener to the radio
station nearest to your home? Now do a bit of research
into the profile – average age and social background.
• Ask somebody at the station if they have an imaginary
listener in mind when they broadcast.
• Imagine a commercial radio station playing your
favourite music. What might be the profile of the
imaginary listener?
Now think of a station playing your parents’ favourite
songs. Would the target audience just consist of older
WORKSHOPS AND EXERCISES
people? Or would they have to broaden the appeal to
attract advertisers?
• Think back over your lifetime. Can you recall five big
stories and remember where you were when you first
heard the news? How did you receive the news? Were
you on your own or in company? How did you react?
• Look at the table on Theories of News Production
(page 23) and decide which model most closely
represents the way news is produced on:
1 BBC News 24
2 Sky News
3 Your local commercial radio station
4 A tabloid newspaper
5 A Sunday broadsheet newspaper.
• Consider the news values, as defined by Harcup and
O’Neill (pages 24 and 25). Watch a TV news bulletin,
listen to news programmes on radio, or consider a
half-hour segment of any rolling news programme –
Radio Five Live or Sky News, for example. Now ask:
• Did all the stories fit into the categories outlined by
Harcup and O’Neill?
• If not, what were the factors that made other stories
newsworthy?
• Does the requirement for balance and impartiality in
broadcast news affect the news agenda?
• Where does sport fit into this list?
• Is broadcast news becoming more or less like
newspaper news?
• How could you make the following stories relevant to
the core audience for an independent local radio station
in Scotland:
1 House prices in the Home Counties are rising by
20 per cent a year.
2 London’s congestion charge is going up again.
3 A budget airline has announced more flights from
Edinburgh airport.
4 Andrew Murray is promoting tennis for young people
at a photo-call in a Central London car park.
5 Firemen in Cardiff have rescued an iguana from a
chimney.
• Consider whether you would want to use any of these
stories at all. Then imagine it is a slow news day – and
you have to use them. How would you treat them? And
what order would you put them in?
Newsdays sections –
show the excitement,
pressure and key
events of days in
real-life newsrooms
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page xiii
BJ_A01.qxd 13/04/2007 13:40 Page xiv