Thi hành bản án, quyết định về lao động vướng mắc từ thực tiễn và một số khuyến nghị

'Jhi hdnh phdp, bi4l 86 10 (331)-2019

THI HANH BA N AN. QUYET DINH v£ LAO DdNG

VUONG MAC Tdr THUC TIEN VA MO T S $ KIEN NGHI • • •

• ThS. NGUVeN TH| PHlP *

& ThS. HOAN G TH | THANH HOA "

Tdm tat; Bii viet phdn tich mgt so vdn de cdn vudng mde tmng thtrc lien thi hinh dn lao dgng, tit do,

dua ra mgt sd kiln nghi nham hoin thiin edc quy dfnh cua phdp lugt ve thi hdnh dn ddn sg vi ndng cao

han nira hilu qud thi hinh dn doi vdi eic vg vile niy.

Abstract: This article analyzes some issues that are still stuck in the practical implementation of labor

judgments, thereby raises some recommendations to impmve the pmvisions of the civil judgment

execution and impmve the judgment execution effectiveness for these cases.

1. Vu'O'ng mac trong thi hanh bdn dn, quyit

d|nh vi lao dpng

Theo Biiu 2 Luit Thi hdnh dn ddn sy ndm

2008 - sda dii, b6 sung ndm 2014 (sau ddy gpi tit

Id Lull Thi hdnh dn ddn sy), thi vi$c thi hdnh cic

bdn dn, quyit djnh vi lao ding (thi hdnh dn lao

ding) Id mil Irong nhdng lo^i viic do co quan thi

hdnh dn ddn sy (THADS) l i chdc thi hdnh. Trang

cde bdn dn, quyil dinh vi lao ding ci rit nhiiu

lo^i nghia vg phdi thi hdnh dn nhu: Nghta vy buic

ngudi sd dyng lao ding nhin ngudi lao ding trd

lal Idm vi$c; nghta vy bil ttiudng tlin luong, tiin

cdng lao ding trong thdi gian ngudi lao ding

khdng dupc Idm vi$c; nghta vy Irp cip mit viic

Idm; nghTa vy trp cip thii viic; nghta vg phii bil

thudng chi phi ddo l?o; cic I09I nghta vg khdc...

Trang qud Irinh ti chdc thi hdnh cic nghta vy

trin, CO quan THADS, chip hdnh viin cin gdp

mil si vudng mic nhil djnh, cg Ihi nhu sau:

Ugt la, w'ic t6 chdv thi hdnh in dii vdi cic

khoin dutfc thi hinh ngay m^c dd ci thi bi khing

do, khdng nghf

Vdi mgc dich bdo ddm kjp thdi quyin, lpi Ich

cho ngudi lao ddng, khodn 2 Biiu 2 Ludt Thi hdnh

dn ddn sy, khodn 2 Oliu 482 BO luit Ti tyng ddn

sy ndm 2015 vd mgc 1 Cdng vdn si

1103/TCTHADS-NV1 ngdy 30/3/2017 cOa Ting

cgc Thi hdnh dn din sy hudng d3n mdt si vin di

vi nghiip vg THADS di quy djnh nhdng khodn

trang bin in, quyit djnh lao ding cOa Tia dn cip

so thim dupc Ihl hdnh ngay mjc dO ci thi bj

khdng cdo, khdng nghj bao gim: Khodn trd cing

lao dOng, nhin ngudi lao ddng trd lai Idm viic trd

luong, trp cip thii vl?c, trp cip mit sdc lao ddng,

trpr cip mit vl^c Idm, bdo hiem xd hdi, bdo hiim

thit nghi$p, bdo hiim y ti, quyit djnh vi tinh hpp

phdp cda cuic dlnh cing... khi cd yiu ciu thi

hdnh dn cia duong sy. Tuy nhiin, trong thyc

tlin, cd nhiiu Irudng hpp, khi co quan THADS dd

hodc dang l4 chdc ttii hdnh dil vdi cic khodn

thuic diin phdl thi hdnh ngay Ihl bdn dn, quyit

djnh b| khdng cdo, khdng nghi vd bdn dn so thim

di dupc xit xd theo ttiu tgc phde thim. Trong mil

si trudng hpp, cip xit xd phOc thim dd hiy hodc

• Hgc viin Tuphdp 'n. Hi Ngi

Ddn chii & Phdp ludt I